While the structure may no longer exist after Monday, many of you had fond memories of dining at Mr. G’s Supper Club. Demolition of the building began at around 9 a.m. and continued for much of the day. Locals and visitors learned of its demise last week after the owner, Bob Geitner, told Door County Daily News and other media outlets that there was too much damage to the building to save it after it fell victim to arson in October 2022.
The announcement elicited over 100 comments on the Door County Daily News Facebook page. Many wished the Geitner family well on their journey, and Bob said that even though he is not rebuilding, he hopes the property stays in the family. Other comments raved about their favorite menu items like steak, coleslaw, and prime rib. One commenter even shared a story from the 1980s when the Geitners allowed them to mail in the remaining balance of their bill when they realized they did not accept credit cards and there was no ATM nearby.
The good news is that the neighboring Fernwood Gardens Ballroom will remain open, where many readers enjoyed other important events. Jonathon J. Polich was arrested in November of 2022 and faced two counts of Arson to Dwelling. He pleaded no contest to the charges and was committed to a mental health facility after a plea deal was reached with the prosecution this past October.
